Review of roland omnes, the interpretation of quantum. Quantum mechanics, a collection of fifteen essays, explores the creative interaction among quantum physics, philosophy, and theology. Consciousness and the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Interpretation of quantum mechanics abstract the consistent histories ch reformulation of quantum mechanics qm was developed by robert gri ths, given a formal logical systematization by roland omn es, and under the label decoherent histories, was independently developed by murray gellmann and james hartle and extended to quantum. Hence the interpretation of quantum mechanics is still very much an open question. The general validity of pure wave mechanics, without any statistical assertions, is assumed for all physical systems, including observers and measuring apparata. The interpretation of quantum mechanics has been controversial since the introduction of quantum theory in the 1920s. It is seen that the richness of quantum physics will greatly a ect the future generation technologies in many aspects. There are so many interpretations of quantum mechanics that it is difficult to summarize all of them succinctly.
Emergent quantum mechanics explores the possibility of an ontology for quantum mechanics. Physicists regularly ignore, and sometimes ridicule, such attempts. The information interpretation of quantum mechanics removes the observer from the moment of the heisenbergvon neumann cut. Many of the interpretations of quantum mechanics deny a central element of quantum theory, one that einstein himself established in 1916, namely the role of indeterminism, or chance, to use its traditional name, as einstein did in physics in german, zufall and as william james did in philosophy in the 1880s.
Consistent histories and the interpretation of quantum mechanics. At the quantum mechanics workshop to which these proceedings are dedicated, held in august 1997 at umbc, the participants were polled as to their preferred interpretation of quantum mechanics. Science philosophical foundations of quantum field. An interpretation of quantum mechanics is an attempt to explain how the mathematical theory of quantum mechanics corresponds to reality. Every quantized system is associated with a definite discrete amount of information 1. Interpretation, quantum mechanics, quantum field theory, ontology 1. This information content remains constant at all times and is permutated oneto. This document was written because of the recognition that with current emphasis on nanotechnology, quantum mechanics is becoming increasingly essential to mechanical engineering.
Pdf consistent histories and the interpretation of. This book is about how to understand quantum mechanics by means of a modal interpretation. A primer on quantum mechanics and its interpretations. Copenhagen interpretation except for an experiment involving a byzantine form of \quantum suicide. A very slightly more scientific poll put copenhagen on top, by a substantial margin.
The manyworlds interpretation is by far the most fantastic interpretation of quantum mechanics. Ebook understanding mechanics as pdf download portable. Every quantized system is associated with a definite discrete amount of information. This fine collection presents the results of the fifth international research conference cosponsored by the vatican observatory, rome, and the center for theology and the. Instead, he just states the theorem in question, and sometimes backs it up with an example or two. Which interpretation of quantum mechanics is generally. However, it is possible to give an overview of the more popular interpretations while also grouping them into categories of like ch.
The problem about quantum mechanics does not lie on its effectivity, but on its interpretation. Fundamental quantum mechanics for engineers leon van dommelen 5507 version 3. Quantum mechanics the interpretation of quantum mechanics. The consistent histories approach to quantum mechanics.
Whether or not probabilities can be given a sensible meaning for individual systems, this motivation is not compelling. Nontechnical overview of the various interpretations of quantum mechanics and their problems. The many interpretations of quantum mechanics scientific. What are current interpretations of quantum mechanics, and. There are no facts to prove any interpretation over the others, but there are some that are more accepted than others. The consistent histories interpretation of quantum mechanics. The copenhagen interpretation ci was the first interpretation of quantum mechanics, and it arose at a time when there was honest confusion and doubt about what quantum mechanics meant.
In this book, roland omnes examines a number of recent advances, which, combined, lead to a consistent. Download pdf philosophic foundations in quantum mechanics. Unlike the copenhagen interpretation, we offer several. The shut up and calculate option was not necessarily available, because the rules for calculation werent yet clear.
The book discusses the basics of physics needed to gain a decent understanding of quantum mechanics, as well as the historical aspects that led scientists to embrace quantum mechanics. Manyworlds interpretation of quantum mechanics stanford. In quantum mechanics, the mathematical formalism is very difficult to interpret physically. A philosophers understanding of quantum mechanics name author. The manyworlds interpretation mwi of quantum mechanics holds that there are many worlds which exist in parallel at the same space and time as our own. But different physicists are satisfied with different interpretations. Download pdf understanding mechanics free online new. Ebook a philosopher s understanding of quantum mechanics. This interpretation says that rather than the wavefunction collapsing, each possibility actually occurs, but in separate universes. Abstract in the information interpretation of quantum mechanics, information is the most fundamental, basic entity. Consistent histories, or decoherent histories, is an interpretation for quantum theory, proposed by griffiths 8, 9, gellmann and hartle 10,11, and omnes 12. The fine structure constant and interpretations of quantum. Most physicists, as students, are introduced to quantum mechanics in a modernphysics course, take quantum mechanics as advanced undergraduates, and then take it again in their first year of graduate school.
The interpretation of quantum mechanics roland omnes. During the last two decades there has been an increased activity concerning the interpretation of quantum mechanics, particularly after the discovery of the important role of the decoherence process for the basic understanding of q. This means that the universes branch off for each possibility. There are presently several interpretations of quantum mechanics. The popular views are defended in hundreds or journal articles and published books. In quantum mechanics a twodimensional complex hilbert space h is used for describing the angular momentum or spin of a spinhalf particle electron, proton, neutron, silver atom, which then provides a. The interpretation of quantum mechanics princeton university press, 1994 a technical exposition of omness account, for physicists. That interpretation is sufficient for every application of quantum theory and it has been confirmed by a countless number of experiments. In an area that has provoked much philosophical debate, omnes has achieved high recognition for his interpretation of quantum mechanics princeton 1994, a book for specialists. This paper takes as its point of departure recent research into the possibility that human beings can perceive single photons. But despite its underlying fundamental mysteries, the theory has remained a cornerstone of modern physics. Although the copenhagen interpretation is commonly accepted, its usual formulation suffers from some serious drawbacks. The second motivation for an ensemble interpretation is the intuition that because quantum mechanics is inherently probabilistic, it only needs to make sense as a theory of ensembles. The ensemble interpretation of quantum mechanics considers the quantum state description to apply only to an ensemble of similarly prepared systems, rather than supposing that it exhaustively represents an individual physical system the advocates of the ensemble interpretation of quantum mechanics claim that it is minimalist, making the fewest physical assumptions about the meaning of the.
Nov 19, 2007 what bothers some people about this interpretation is the random, abrupt change in the wave function, which violates the schrodinger equation, the very heart of quantum mechanics. Although quantum mechanics has been applied to problems in physics with great success, some of its ideas seem strange. Youngs aforementioned experiment in which a parallel beam of monochromatic light is passed through a pair of narrow parallel slits figure 5a. The consistent histories, also known as decoherent histories, approach to quantum interpretation is broadly compatible with standard quantum mechanics as found in textbooks. The structure and interpretation of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics quantum mechanics the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Minimal interpretation and total interpretations abstract in this paper i contend that standard quantum theory has a minimal interpretation, on which all physicists agree. My own conclusion is that today there is no interpretation of quantum mechanics that does not have serious flaws. Although quantum mechanics has held up to rigorous and extremely precise tests in an extraordinarily broad range of experiments not one prediction from quantum mechanics is found to be contradicted by experiments, there exist a number of contending schools. Although quantum mechanics has held up to rigorous and extremely precise tests in an extraordinarily broad range of experiments not one prediction from quantum mechanics is found to be contradicted by experiments, there exist a number of contending. These ideas as to what is really going on behind quantum mechanics. The quantum archangel download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. This video is about interpretations of the branch of physics, quantum mechanics.
The single term histories will be employed below, with the understanding that at points where. Here roland omnes offers a clear, uptodate guide to the conceptual framework of quantum mechanics. This thesis inquires what it means to interpret nonrelativistic quantum mechanics qm, and the philosophical limits of this interpretation. Indeed, many physicists are satisfied with their own interpretation of quantum mechanics. Many, perhaps most, are attempts to eliminate the element of chance or indeterminism that is involved in the socalled collapse of the wave function. Griffiths carnegiemellon submitted on 16 may 1995 abstract. Introduction interpreting quantum mechanics has flourished as a cottage industry among philosophers of science and some philosophically inclined physicists. Interpretations of quantum mechanics and the measurement problem by marco genovese 201002 a short introduction to the quantum formalisms by francois david 201211 on the problem of the interpretation of quantum physics by a.
This book will be very useful for historians as well any philosophers working on the development of interpretations of quantum theory. In order to appreciate what quantum perception may entail, we first explore several of the leading interpretations of quantum mechanics, then consider an alternative view based on the ontological phenomenology of maurice merleauponty and martin heidegger. Improving students understanding of quantum mechanics. Understanding quantum mechanics princeton university press. The information interpretation of quantum mechanics. Fans of mwi, unsurprisingly, found that most people agree with mwi. The interpretation of quantum mechanics britannica. Omnes interpretation of quantum mechanics is summarized, and compared with other consistenthistory approaches by gellmann and hartle, and by griffiths. Now the author has transformed his own theory into a short and readable text that enables beginning students and.
Interpretations of quantum mechanics simple english. One element of the authors approach to this topic that makes his treatment more accessible to the reader is his general avoidance of mathematical proofs. This cut is when information is created about the interaction of the quantum system with another system which may be a measurement apparatus. However, there are many ideas about the interpretations and meanings of quantum mechanics. Hellwig, zentralblatt math the book is a mandatory read for anyone interested in the history of the philosophy of quantum mechanics. Introduction at the quantum mechanics workshop to which these. A primer on quantum mechanics and its interpretations casey blood professor emeritus of physics, rutgers university sarasota, fl email. In pursuit of a scientificrealist stance, a metametaphysical method is expanded and applied to evaluate rival interpretations of qm, based on the conceptual distinction between ontology and metaphysics, for objective theory choice in metaphysical. The success and universal applicability of quantum mechanics are now wellestablished at a level unequaled by any other theory in the history of science. To assume the universal validity of the quantum description, by the complete abandonment of process 1. The existence of the other worlds makes it possible to remove randomness and action at a distance from quantum theory and thus from all physics. This makes the choice between them purely a matter of taste, roughly equivalent to whether one believes mathematical language or human language to be more fundamental. However, the concept of measurement by which probabilities are introduced in standard quantum theory no longer plays a fundamental role. Ebook a philosopher s understanding of quantum mechanics as.
The statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics is also explained in terms of hilbert space. This information content remains constant at all times and is permutated onetoone throughout the system evolution. As with our analysis of positions on the free will problem, there are many interpretations, some very popular with many adherents, some with only a few supporters. Nov 28, 2009 the book discusses the basics of physics needed to gain a decent understanding of quantum mechanics, as well as the historical aspects that led scientists to embrace quantum mechanics. Interpretations of quantum mechanics an encyclopedia of. Polls have been conducted, but the population is too small to make meaningful extrapolations. Perspectives on quantum reality download ebook pdf, epub. The information interpretation is simply standard quantum physics plus information being recorded irreversibly. Understanding quantum mechanics princeton university press, 1999 a somewhat less technical revision and updating of the above work, also intended for physicists. Wikipedia has a most comprehensive page on the interpretations of quantum mechanics. Plenty of diagrams and analogies aid in the understanding of the topic.
1256 1304 914 1197 112 1028 615 656 1156 1617 987 1112 1668 514 1306 1581 783 1622 222 1074 601 607 862 1181 197 280 297 1438